The reasoning you can see is a setting, not a window
When a model prints "let me think step by step" it is easy to feel you are watching it think. Gary Marcus, on stage with Brian Greene, says the quiet part: the visible trace is a disclosure setting chosen by the lab, not a window into the computation, and lately labs show less of it so competitors cannot copy the steps.
In favour- Apple's "Illusion of Thinking" is the clean demo: a model that solves Tower of Hanoi at seven disks and collapses at eight, where a child applies the rule.
- The progress on hard problems comes from symbolic scaffolding around the model (provers, interpreters, loops), which the industry rarely names because "scaling" is the fundraising story.
- Marcus has been predicting the wall for years; the wall keeps moving. Take the epistemics, discount the forecast.
- A benchmark score is a surface the optimiser can satisfy without doing what you meant, like the classifier that told wolves from huskies by the snow.
Our takeDo not read the reasoning as the reason, and do not read a passing eval as the capability. Trust the outcome you verified, not the explanation you were shown.
Source: Gary Marcus με τον Brian Greene, World Science Festival (YouTube)
← All Focus posts